A Fictitious Attribution

By Jacinta Horgan All Rights Reserved ©

Mystery / Thriller


On her sixteenth birthday, Emma received a card through the post. It was from the father who she had always believed died in a car accident, along with her mother, when she was four years old. Visiting him in prison, she learns of the secrets of her own past, which have been kept from her, by her grandparents, Patrick, her father, is serving a prison sentence for the murder of, Emma's mother, information she had been kept unaware of. Wishing to exonerate Patrick, Emma chases down the truth of what happened to her mother one night twelve years previous, despite numerous warnings against doing so. Once she discovers the true identity of her mother's murderer, Emma finds herself conflicted between two options; clearing a supposedly innocent man's name, or, keeping the truth, unknown to all but two people, buried, as it always has been. Both choices will have a grueling impact on Emma for the rest of her life.

Birthday Card

On the afternoon of my sixteenth birthday, my life was irrevocably changed. I had left school early to avoid my insanely boring double period maths, coupled with my religion class. As I entered into my home, the doormat was swept aside by the door, causing the pile of daily post to become scattered along the wooden floorboards of the hallway.

I scooped the letters into my hand and tossed them onto the pine unit in the hall of my grandparents’ house. As I began to step away, the pink envelope jutting from the bottom of the pile caught my eye. It was addressed to me, my name written on it in a messy scrawl of black ink. I didn’t recognize the handwriting, so I picked it up curiously and began to break the seal. I drew the card out of its glossy envelope and looked to the front of it.

To a special daughter on her sixteenth birthday, it read.

For a moment, I thought I had misread the card. Upon scanning my eyes over it again, I realized this was not the case. I turned the envelope back over in my hand out of utter perplexity and re-read the address, assuming there had been some kind of mistake in the distribution of the card.

Emma Fitzgerald, 14 Greenwood Road, Ashfield, County Wicklow was the address on the torn envelope. My address. All I kept thinking was that this couldn’t have been possible, for both of my parents had died in a car accident when I was four years old. I hesitantly opened the card to read the message inside, not knowing what to anticipate.

Happy birthday Emma. I can’t believe you’re sixteen. I love you and I always will. Hope your day is filled with lots of love and joy,


At first, I thought that this was some kind of sick joke. As far as I was concerned, my father was dead and had been for a longer period of my life than he had been alive. But then, I pulled out the letter that was also contained inside the envelope. I unfolded it, and began to read the mass of writing.

Hello Emma.

How are you getting on? I’ve missed you these past twelve years and I’d really like to get in touch with you.

As I’ve repeated in almost every previous letter that I’ve included with each of your birthday cards over the past number of years, I want to emphasise that despite having been found guilty, I never did it. I know that I’m not in a good light considering the evidence against me, but I want you to know that I am innocent. I know you probably don’t believe me and that’s likely the reason that you’ve not replied to any of my letters. I understand if you hate me for everything that happened. But please give me the chance to convince you that I’m not guilty. Please come and visit me and let me explain everything. If you then decide you don’t believe me and still want nothing to do with me, then I’ll accept that and I won’t contact you again. If you don’t respond to this letter, I’ll take that as you’re not interested and I’ll also leave you alone under that circumstance. Either way, this is the last time that I’ll contact you through a letter.

I hope to hear from you soon. But if that doesn’t happen, I just want you to know that I love and miss you dearly. Not a day has gone by over the last twelve years when I haven’t thought of you.

Take care Emma,


Welling tears began to sting at my eyes. My dad was alive. In that instant, I couldn’t comprehend that being the reality. Nor could I handle the overwhelming amount of knowledge that had just been sprung on me. And yet, I was craving more information on the matter. My father was in prison for something that he claimed he didn’t do. What his supposed crime was, I was unaware of and my grandparents had always kept this from me. He had also claimed to have written more letters to me in the past, which was a clear indication that they had intercepted each one of them being delivered to me.

With that in mind, I decided I wasn’t going to reveal I was now privy of this to them, at least not until I became more acquainted with the truths of the past they had kept from me. I resolved to keep this hidden from them as they had so done with me, until I had visited my father in prison.

Continue Reading Next Chapter
Further Recommendations

Khodges: The hunt aahhhhhh!!! However Jackieboy is awake🐣

Sara Gomes: vfdethjjvcddssssw

FluffyUnicorn : This story was so fricken awesome! I really enjoyed reading this story and the ending was just perfect to wrap up the whole thing. I loved it! Not gonna lie cried a little while reading this story but other than that I really, really, really liked it. This is probably by far one of the best stori...

cinnabonmaki: I recommend it, it’s highly entertaining with many plot twists, you wouldn’t see it coming. 😁

Maame Ama Nyarko: I hope the next chapter is coming soon cause it's an interesting story. Izzy and Thomas are great main characters.

Stormy Sparks: Great start to a story. Can't stand Amanda and Tai is a weak asshole. Love wyatt, Carter, and the MC.

DrDimpy Ajmera: Beautifully written, couldnt stop reading and could imagine the plot for real..Enjoyed reading every bit of it..

elizabethmaina: Awesome. Great read

More Recommendations

mackenzyv: Loved it sm

Marina Gudon: love reading this story

rsalisbury: I loved this book!It was filled with adventure and excitement at every turn.DT Jones is a fantastic writer, and I cannot wait to read Trust Me III.Thank you DT Jones!

Pie Chan: I like it, it's not a bad read for me. It's quite entertaining. I have questions about the characters but because it's a mystery... I have no further questions to ask. Justin Case is a good name. A good read for me.

Anonymous_Writer: I LOVE ITI really love this book and this is one of the very few detective stories I loveIm just starting to read HOPE and as I can see it is focused on Mystery than Romance but IF EVER you make another book I hope it will focus more on Lukas and Bo's lovestory💕

About Us:

Inkitt is the world’s first reader-powered book publisher, offering an online community for talented authors and book lovers. Write captivating stories, read enchanting novels, and we’ll publish the books you love the most based on crowd wisdom.